← all projects

Jan Karski coal mine (Lublin Coal Basin)

cancelledstage: permitsabandoned
USD 632 million
estimate · data from 2 Jun 2016net or gross: not recorded≈ PLN 2.5 billion (value-by-stage, est., nominal)Capital expenditure from the 2016 pre-feasibility study.Limitations: the amount recorded at the current stage, nominal, not adjusted for inflation. The total cost of the project may differ.

A planned hard coal mine, Jan Karski, on the Lublin deposit in the Lublin Coal Basin, near Kulik in the Siedliszcze commune. The investor was the Australian company Prairie Mining, now GreenX Metals. A 2016 pre-feasibility study assumed capital expenditure of USD 631.7 million. The concession for the central part of the deposit went to Bogdanka, and the mine was never built. In October 2024 an arbitration tribunal found that Poland had breached its treaty obligations toward the company.

Why it failed

Prairie Mining did not obtain a concession for the central part of the Lublin deposit, which went to Bogdanka, and the mine was not built. In October 2024 an international arbitration tribunal unanimously found that Poland had breached its treaty obligations toward the company with respect to the Jan Karski project.

How it went

No outcome assessment on this card. This is not a fault: we show an assessment only where a source quote stands behind it. Of the four axes, 3 carry no assessment yet, one has an assessment with no confirmed quote. The timeline and sources below show what is known about the project. How to read this section

Change history

  • Oct 2024status: cancelledAn arbitration tribunal found that Poland had breached its treaty obligations with respect to the project.

Significance

The project never went beyond the permitting stage. The tribunal awarded the company about PLN 1.3 billion under the Polish-Australian investment treaty and about PLN 940 million under the Energy Charter Treaty. In December 2024 a deputy minister of climate and environment said the compensation had not been paid because Poland had filed a complaint against the ruling.

Sources 3 · 3 independent

Every fact on this card comes from the sources below. Next to sources with a quote you can see which fields they support.

Independence is counted the same way the gate that admits a record counts it: subdomains and titles from one publisher are a single voice, Wikipedia is zero. That is why the number is lower than the number of links. Three is the minimum.

  1. Forsal.pl2 Jun 2016
    StageCost
    Stagedo Regionalnej Dyrekcji Ochrony Środowiska trafił wniosek o wydanie decyzji o uwarunkowaniach środowiskowych inwestycji
    Costprzy zakładanym capex na poziomie 631,7 mln USD
  2. Radio Lublin9 Oct 2024
    StatusInvestorFailure description
    StatusChodzi o niedoszłą budowę kopalni Jan Karski na terenie województwa lubelskiego.
    InvestorSpółka GreenX Metals, dawniej Praire Mining, planowała inwestycję w Lubelskim Zagłębiu Węglowym.
    Failure descriptionTrybunał jednogłośnie uznał, że Rzeczpospolita Polska naruszyła swoje zobowiązania wynikające z traktatów w odniesieniu do projektu Jan Karski
  3. Parkiet18 Dec 2024
    Failure description
    Failure descriptionudzielono Bogdance